Overview
Erie offers significantly lower rates and top-rated customer service but is only available in 12 states. Travelers is available nationwide with strong home insurance. Both companies are major players in the U.S. insurance market with strong financial ratings and nationwide availability.
Rate Comparison
Travelers offers an average auto rate of $1,650/yr while Erie Insurance averages $1,290/yr. For home insurance, Travelers averages $1,620/yr vs Erie Insurance at $1,280/yr.
Customer Satisfaction
In customer satisfaction surveys, Travelers scores 820/1000 while Erie Insurance scores 875/1000. For claims handling specifically, Travelers rates as Good and Erie Insurance rates as Excellent.
Who Should Choose Which?
Travelers is best for: Nationwide home insurance.
Erie Insurance is best for: Best rates and service (12 states).
Our Recommendation
Our winner is Erie where available. However, insurance is highly personal — the best company for you depends on your specific profile, location, and coverage needs. We always recommend comparing quotes from both companies (and at least 3-4 others) to find your best rate.